By Patrice Brymner
There are fourteen county-elected sheriffs in
Massachusetts, responsible primarily for operating
county correctional facilities. Sheriffs are among
a small group of officials elected at the county
level, and they operate under an unusual combination
of voter accountability and autonomy.
Nearly all sheriffs—thirteen of the fourteen—operate
correctional facilities.1 The combined
population
of these facilities, about 12,000, is greater than
the entire population of the state prison system,
about 10,000. County facilities house men and women
as prisoners awaiting trial and as convicted
prisoners serving sentences of up to 2 ½ years.
Throughout New England, county governments do not
exist in the same manner as they do in most other
states. In Massachusetts, county governance, or
lack thereof, varies from county to county. Some
counties maintain select functions, such as
registries of deeds. Barnstable County has adopted
a Home Rule Charter and maintains county-level
governance that exceeds other counties.2
In contrast, eight county governments have been
officially abolished: Berkshire, Essex, Franklin,
Hampden, Hampshire, Middlesex, Worcester, and
Suffolk.3
All fourteen counties elect sheriffs and maintain
sheriff’s departments funded through the state
budget and, in some cases, through county-generated
funding.4 Total funding to sheriffs in
FY05 was about $450 million, compared with about
$700 million in funding for state prisons.
Statewide, county corrections spending averages
about $35,000 per prisoner each year; state prisons
average about $44,000 per prisoner each year.
Sheriffs are elected to six-year terms, and as
elected officials, are accountable in ways that
other corrections officials are not. Unlike the
Department of Correction, which operates state
prisons under an appointed commissioner, sheriffs
must answer to voters and respond to challengers
every six years. At the same time, sheriffs are
also independent managers, not subject to direct
oversight by any state agency or official, and
traditionally, each department has enjoyed
considerable autonomy. This freedom has allowed
some sheriffs to pursue significant innovation,
while others (none current) have veered toward
corruption and left office amidst scandal,
eventually finding themselves in prison.5
What Sheriffs Do
Sheriffs are responsible for some law enforcement as
well as certain civil functions, including the
service of eviction notices and subpoenas. In all
but Nantucket County, each sheriff’s primary
responsibility is the operation of jails and houses
of correction. Sheriffs are responsible for the
hiring and training of personnel, the negotiation of
union contracts, the establishment and enforcement
of policies and procedures, as well as all
programming offered to prisoners.
The daily functions of the fourteen sheriffs’
departments vary, depending on a given department’s
programs and facilities. Some sheriffs’ departments
maintain law enforcement divisions, assisting local
law enforcement agencies; some maintain
investigation or intelligence divisions; and many
participate in various community education and
safety programs. The Bristol, Hampden, and Suffolk
sheriffs’ departments operate facilities for women
serving county sentences (up to 2 ½ years).
Some departments also operate very specialized
programs or facilities. Bristol County’s Juvenile
Alternative Lock-Up is a juvenile-specific holding
facility serving local law enforcement agencies that
do not have juvenile-appropriate facilities. Essex
County’s Women in Transition Center is a facility
for women nearing completion of state prison
sentences at MCI-Framingham as they prepare to
re-enter community life. Two departments, Middlesex
and Hampden, recently received $2.6 million to fund
regional behavioral evaluation and stabilization
units, providing forensic mental health services to
prisoners. The Hampden facility serves prisoners
from Berkshire, Franklin, Hampden, Hampshire, and
Worcester Counties; and the Middlesex unit serves
prisoners from Barnstable, Bristol, Dukes, Essex,
Nantucket, Middlesex, Norfolk, Plymouth, and Suffolk
Counties. One stated goal for the new units is to
alleviate the county prisoner caseload at
Bridgewater State Hospital.
Sheriffs’ departments in all counties but Nantucket
and Plymouth participate to some degree in Community
Corrections programs.6 Community
Corrections Centers operate as a partnership among
sheriffs, probation and parole officials, and the
Massachusetts Office of Community Corrections, which
received $12,109,135 in funding in the FY05 state
budget. The centers offer drug testing, day
reporting for non-incarcerated offenders as an
alternative to prison, electronic monitoring, and in
some cases, substance abuse treatment. Most
participating offenders are supervised by the Board
of Parole or by a probation department, but others
are supervised by a sheriff’s department or, in a
few cases, the Department of Youth Services. Some
sheriffs’ departments, such as Essex, Hampshire,
Suffolk, and Worcester, have relatively high
supervision rates, while others, such as Bristol and
Middlesex, supervise very few
offenders.7
As a group, the fourteen sheriffs make up the
membership of the Massachusetts Sheriffs’
Association (MSA). MSA has operated as a voluntary
association for several years, and is currently
seeking greater legislative recognition for its
efforts.8 MSA is a state-funded agency,
staffed by an executive director, and led by a
president elected from its membership. The
association’s current president is Sheriff James M.
Cummings of Barnstable County. MSA’s budget for
FY06 is $344,300. The legislature approved this
funding to coordinate and standardize services and
programs, to collect and analyze data on
incarceration and recidivism, and to provide
technical assistance and training to ensure
standardization in organization, operations, and
procedures.
The Sheriffs and their Departments
The Commonwealth’s current sheriffs are a fairly
diverse group, with backgrounds in education, social
work, law enforcement, military service, and law.
Some have held other public office, some have worked
in business, and some have been elected from within
the sheriff’s department they now manage.
-
Five sheriffs are Republicans, eight are
Democrats, and one is registered as
Democrat/Republican/GreenRainbow (Sheriff
Bretschneider of Nantucket).
- At least seven sheriffs have backgrounds in law
enforcement: two were state troopers, three worked
in municipal police departments, one was a probation
officer, and one was a corrections officer.
- At least eight sheriffs have military backgrounds;
at least two have worked as educators; one has a
background in social work; and two current sheriffs
are attorneys.
- Five sheriffs have held other elected offices: two
have been state representatives, one was a state
senator, one was a county commissioner, and one was
elected as both a state representative and a city
councilor.
- At least ten of the fourteen sheriffs hold college
degrees; at least seven hold graduate degrees.
- Twelve of the sheriffs are white, and two are
African-American (Cousins of Essex and Cabral of
Suffolk).
- One of the fourteen sheriffs is female (Cabral of
Suffolk).
- Half of the state’s fourteen sheriffs have been in
office less than ten years.
Long-time sheriffs, in office more than ten years,
are found exclusively in the western part of the
state: Sheriff Michael J. Ashe of Hampden County
(since 1974), Sheriff Carmen Massimiano of Berkshire
County (since 1978), Sheriff Robert Garvey of
Hampshire County (since 1984), and Sheriff Frederick
MacDonald of Franklin County (since 1992). All
sheriffs east of and including Worcester County came
to office within the last ten years, and seven
entered office since 1998.
What follows is a brief description of each county’s
sheriff and department, including the sheriff’s
background, the department’s budget, and the
corrections population.9 Also
included are notes on some special programs or
facilities. These descriptions are not comprehensive
and are meant to illustrate the range of services and
programs offered by some departments and differences
among departments.
Barnstable County. Sheriff James M. Cummings (R)
is a native of South Boston and was first elected in
1998. Prior to becoming sheriff, Cummings was a
detective with the Massachusetts State Police,
investigating organized crime, and served as a
court-qualified expert on organized crime/gaming,
narcotics, and arson. Sheriff Cummings holds a
bachelor’s degree in Law Enforcement from
Northeastern University and a master’s degree in
Criminal Justice from Anna Maria College. Cummings
served in the U.S. Navy.
The Barnstable Sheriff’s Department’s FY05 budget
was $19,875,908, with an estimated daily corrections
population of 312, for annual per prisoner spending
of approximately $63,705. This department receives
funding through the state budget as well as from
county generated revenue.
Cummings’s department administers a sex offender
warrant program, supporting the Cape Cod regional
sex offender management task force by providing
address verification and maintenance of a regional
sex offender database for local law enforcement.
Cummings’s department also operates youth programs,
including a “Youth Academy” offered three times each
year in partnership with local law enforcement,
educators, and treatment facilities. The department
has special programs aimed at preventing crime
against seniors. Currently, the Barnstable
Sheriff’s Department is involved in Operation
Helping Hand, assisting evacuees from New Orleans.
For more information on the Barnstable County
Sheriff’s Department, see www.bsheriff.net.
Berkshire County. Sheriff Carmen C. Massimiano,
Jr. (D) is a native of Pittsfield and was first elected
in 1978. Before becoming sheriff, Massimiano was
chief probation officer of Berkshire Superior Court.
He holds a bachelor’s degree in Sociology from St.
Anselm’s College, a master’s degree in Criminal
Justice Administration from American International
College, and an honorary law degree from North Adams
State College.
The Berkshire County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05
budget was $12,842,33, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 338, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $37,995. This
department receives funding through the state
budget.
Massimiano’s department operates a communications
center in Pittsfield, providing emergency and
non-emergency communications for police, fire, and
ambulance service to twenty-three cities and
towns. The department also oversees a juvenile
resource center and maintains an underwater search
and rescue
team.
Bristol County. Sheriff Thomas M. Hodgson
(R) was appointed sheriff in 1997 by then-Governor
William Weld. Prior to his appointment, Hodgson was
assistant deputy superintendent of investigations
for the Bristol County Sheriff’s Office. He also
served five years as councilor-at-large on the New
Bedford City Council and was a police officer in
Maryland.
The Bristol County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05
budget was $40,622,636, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 1,202, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $33,796. This
department receives funding through the state
budget.
Hodgson’s department is one of three in the state to
operate a county-level women’s correctional
facility. The department also maintains a law
enforcement division, including K-9 and marine
units, and operates a juvenile alternative lock-up
facility, serving local law enforcement agencies.
The department also participates in community safety
programs for children and seniors. For more
information on the Bristol County Sheriff’s
Department, go to www.bcso-ma.us.
Dukes County. Sheriff Michael A. McCormack (D) was
first elected in 2004. McCormack worked for 12
years in the sheriff’s department prior to his
election, and was an Oaks Bluff police officer prior
to joining the sheriff’s department. He has served
on the personnel boards of several towns on Martha’s
Vineyard.
The Dukes County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05 budget
was $2,743,050, with an estimated daily corrections
population of 26, for annual per prisoner spending
of approximately $105,502. This department receives
funding through the state budget, as well as from
county generated revenue.
McCormack’s department has partnered with local
agencies to introduce a “3-1-1” telephone service
for urgent, non-emergency (non-9-1-1) matters. The
new number is not yet in operation. The department
also participates in a local drug task force and an
anti-litter campaign. For more information on the
Dukes County Sheriff’s Department, go to www.dukescounty.org/
and link to “County Services.”
Essex County. Sheriff Frank Cousins, Jr. (R)
is a native of Newburyport and was appointed in
1996, and first elected in 1998. Before becoming
sheriff, Cousins served as a state representative
(1st Essex) and Newburyport city councilor. Cousins
holds a bachelor’s degree in Human Services and a
master’s degree in Criminal Justice.
The Essex County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05 budget
was $39,701,005, with an estimated daily corrections
population of 1,443, for annual per prisoner
spending of approximately $27,513. This department
receives funding through the state budget.
Cousins’s department operates the Women in
Transition Center, the only facility of its kind in
Massachusetts, serving women nearing the end of
their state sentences at MCI-Framingham. Most of
the women are preparing to return to community life
in Essex County. For more information on the Essex
County Sheriff’s Department, go to www.eccf.com/
Franklin County. Sheriff Frederick B. Macdonald (D)
was first elected sheriff in 1992. Macdonald had
retired as a lieutenant after twenty-four years with
Massachusetts State Police. He is a graduate of
Quinsigamond Community College and attended Clark
University and Boston College while with the State
Police.
The Franklin County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05
budget was $6,136,081, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 178, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $34,472. This
department receives funding through the state
budget. For more information on the Franklin County
Sheriff’s Department, go to www.fcso-ma.com.
Hampden County. Sheriff Michael J. Ashe, Jr.
(D) was first elected in 1974. Prior to becoming
sheriff, Ashe and his wife were the first house
parents for the Downey Side Home for Youths. Ashe
holds a bachelor’s degree from St. Anselm’s College
and a master’s degree in Social Work from Boston
College.
The Hampden County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05
budget was $53,943,889, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 1,861, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $28,987. This
department receives funding through the state
budget.
Ashe’s department operates the Hampden County
Pre-Release Minimum Center, a residential facility,
whose stated goal “successful reintegration back
into the community.” The program serves men and
women, and a total of about 850 prisoners each
year. The department also operates the Western
Massachusetts Correctional Alcohol Center, a minimum
security, co-ed, community-based, residential
treatment facility, providing treatment to addicted
prisoners from Berkshire, Franklin, Hampden,
Hampshire, and Worcester Counties. Ashe’s
department also runs a Community Safety Center, in
downtown Springfield, which houses the department’s
community corrections programs, including Hampden
County’s After Incarceration Support Systems. For
more information on the Hampden County Sheriff’s
Department, go to: www.hcsdmass.org.
Hampshire County. Hampshire County Sheriff
Robert J. Garvey (D) is a native of Amherst. He was
appointed sheriff in 1984 and first elected in 1986.
Prior to becoming sheriff, Garvey taught school,
served as a town selectman in Amherst, and as
Hampshire County Commissioner. Sheriff Garvey holds
a bachelor’s degree in Physical Sciences from
Springfield College and a master’s degree in
Education from UMass-Amherst. Since being sheriff,
Garvey has taught Sociology at UMass-Amherst and
Criminal Justice at Holyoke Community College and
Anna Maria College.
The Hampshire County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05
budget was $10,430,689, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 272, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $38,348. This
department receives funding through the state budget.
Members of the Hampshire sheriff’s department
participate in the national radKIDS program,
educating children ages five through ten in the
county about personal safety. For more information
on the Hampshire County Sheriff’s Department, go to
www.hampshiresheriffs.com/.
Middlesex County. Sheriff James V. DiPaola (D)
was first elected in 1996 in a special election to
complete the last two years of the former sheriff’s
term. Prior to being elected sheriff, DiPaola
served two terms as a state representative (36th
Middlesex - Malden), and before that he was an
officer with the Malden Police Department. DiPaola
has served over twenty-five years in the military
reserves (branch of service not stated).
The Middlesex County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05
budget was $48,620,821, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 1,159, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $41,951. This
department receives funding through the state
budget.
DiPaola’s department sponsors a Youth Public Safety
Academy each summer; provides K-9 searches for
schools in partnership with the Middlesex County
District Attorney’s office and local police as part
of a zero drug-tolerance effort; runs a “Strike Two”
program, which gives tours of the Billerica HOC for
“at-risk” students or interested community groups;
and operates a Victim Services Unit from the
Billerica facility, offering post-conviction
information and support services to crime victims.
More information on the Middlesex County Sheriff’s
Department, is at middlesexsheriff.org/.
Nantucket County. Sheriff Richard M.
Bretschneider (D/R/Green-Rainbow) was first elected
sheriff in 1998. Before becoming sheriff,
Bretschneider worked as a police officer. He holds
a bachelor’s degree in Criminal Justice.
The Nantucket County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05
budget was $858,298, with no corrections population.
This department receives funding through the state
budget, as well as from county generated revenue.
Bretschneider’s Department serves court process,
transports prisoners, handles evictions, coordinates
certain state programs, and is responsible for
prisoners after court sentencing, but does not
maintain a correctional facility. For more
information on the Nantucket County Sheriff’s
Department, go to www.nantucket-ma.gov/departments/sheriff.html
.
Norfolk County. Norfolk County Sheriff
Michael G. Bellotti (D) is a native of Quincy and
was first elected sheriff in 1998. Before becoming
sheriff, Bellotti served three terms as a state
representative (1st Norfolk - Quincy and Randolph).
Prior to that, Bellotti was a sales and marketing
representative and owned a small business on the
south shore. Bellotti holds a bachelor’s degree
from Boston College.
The Norfolk County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05
budget was $27,272,812, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 552, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $49,407. This
department receives funding through the state
budget, as well as from county generated revenue.
Bellotti’s Department operates or participates in
several community based programs, including: DARE; a
jail tours program; a school essay program; and
programs aimed at senior citizen safety and
well-being, including a “Are You O.K.?” and “File
for Life.” The department also maintains a K-9
unit. The department’s victim assistance program
includes a Cells For Safety Program, providing free
cell phones for 9-1-1 service, in partnership with
local police. For more information on the Norfolk
County Sheriff’s Department, go to www.norfolksheriff.com/.
Plymouth County. Sheriff Joseph D. McDonald
(R) was elected sheriff in 2004. McDonald had
previously worked for eight years as an assistant
district attorney for Plymouth County. McDonald
holds a bachelor’s degree from the University if
Massachusetts, and a law degree from Suffolk
University Law School. McDonald has taught criminal
justice and history at Quincy College in Plymouth.
The Plymouth County Sheriff’s Department’ FY05
budget was $49,949,398, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 1,570, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $31,815. This
department receives funding through the state
budget, as well as from county generated revenue.
McDonald’s department operates the largest
correctional facility under one roof in New England
and is one of the largest employers in Plymouth
County. This department runs a secure juvenile
facility and operates a Field Services Division,
supporting local law enforcement with K-9, warrant
apprehension, mounted, motorcycle, and honor guard
units, as well as a criminal bureau of
investigation. The department’s Communications Unit
coordinates all fire mutual aid calls in Plymouth
county, acts as the communications link between
paramedics and hospitals, and provides
communications services for major events. For more
information on the Plymouth County Sheriff’s
Department, go to www.pcsdma.org/.
Suffolk County. Sheriff Andrea Cabral (D) was
elected sheriff in 2004. Before her election,
Cabral worked as an attorney for the Suffolk County
Sheriff’s Department and for the Suffolk County
District Attorney’s Office. Cabral is a graduate of
Boston College and holds a law degree from Suffolk
University Law School. Cabral was the first female
sheriff in the Commonwealth.
The Suffolk County Sheriff’s Department’ FY05 budget
was $100,244,966, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 2,419, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $41,441. This
department receives funding through the state budget
as well as from county generated revenue.
Cabral’s Department operates a Legal Services
Division, providing counsel and representation, in
selected cases, regarding the right to a bail
appeal. This division also provides legal research
upon request by prisoners remaining in custody
during trial, and handles commitments to
Bridgewater State Hospital for 30-day psychiatric
evaluation. The sheriff’s department participates
in prisoner re-entry programs, including the
Boston Reentry Initiative, in partnership with the
Boston Police Department; the Offender entry
Program (ORP), facilitated by the Suffolk County
Community Corrections Division; and Community
Re-entry for Women (CREW), in partnership with local
human service providers. The sheriff's department
also works with the Department of Revenue to educate
prisoners about child support obligations, and an
enforcement function will be implemented in the
future to garnish prisoner funds for payment of
child support. For more information on the Suffolk
County Sheriff’s Department, go to www.scsdma.org/.
Worcester County. Worcester County Sheriff Guy
Glodis (D) was first elected sheriff in 2004.
Before becoming sheriff, Glodis served as a state
senator and worked as a corrections officer. He
holds a bachelor’s degree in Political Science and
has done some graduate studies in public policy.
The Worcester County Sheriff’s Department’s FY05
budget was $38,034,321, with an estimated daily
corrections population of 1,316, for annual per
prisoner spending of approximately $28,901. This
department receives funding through the state budget.
For more information on the Worcester County
Sheriff’s Department, go to
www.worcestercountysheriff.com/.
CJPC encourages readers to learn more about their
sheriffs’ departments and departments throughout
the state by visiting our County
Corrections Project (updated frequently) and by
contacting sheriff’s departments directly.
CJPC is grateful to the Massachusetts Sheriffs’
Association and the following sheriffs and their
departments for their cooperation in our research:
Sheriff Michael J. Ashe of Hampden County, Sheriff
Frank Cousins of Essex County, Sheriff James M.
Cummings of Barnstable County, Sheriff Robert J.
Garvey of Hampshire County, and Sheriff Carmen C.
Massimiano of Berkshire County.
FOOTNOTES
1 Nantucket County does not maintain a
correctional facility.
2 See the Barnstable County home page,
www.barnstablecounty.org.
3 For more information on counties,
their functions and/or abolition, see the League of
Women Voters, “Massachusetts Government: County
Government,” (Boston: LWVMA),
http://lwvma.org/govcounty.shtml,
and see Secretary of the Commonwealth, Citizen
Information Service, “Historical Data Relating to the
Incorporation of and Abolishment of Counties in the
Commonwealth of Massachusetts,” (Boston: Secretary
of the Commonwealth),
www.sec.state.ma.us/cis/cisctlist/ctlistcounin.htm
4 Counties that have not abolished their
governments combine state funding with
county-generated tax revenue. Sheriff’s departments
in abolished counties are funded entirely through
the state budget. Although officially abolished,
Suffolk County receives county-generated funding.
5 In 1994, John McGonigle, former Sheriff of
Middlesex County, was convicted and sentenced to
nearly five years in federal prison for extorting
money from his deputies; in 1996, Charles Reardon,
former Sheriff of Essex County, was indicted and
pled guilty to corruption charges.
6 See the Massachusetts Office of
Community Corrections pages,
www.mass.gov/courts/admin/communitycorrections.html.
7 Massachusetts Office of Community
Corrections, Utilization of Community Corrections
Centers Statistical Report, FY 2004 (Boston:
Massachusetts Office of Community Corrections, 2005),
www.mass.gov/courts/admin/occ/statreport2004.pdf.
8 For more information on MSA’s
legislative agenda, go to the CJPC County
Corrections Project:
http://www.cjpc.org/RelatedLegislation.htm.
9 For detailed information on budgets,
corrections populations, and other specifics, please
go to
www.cjpc.org/and
link to the County Corrections
Project pages.